Tools for Saving: Using Prepaid Accounts to Set Aside Funds

27 Pages Posted: 27 Nov 2018

See all articles by Cheryl R. Cooper

Cheryl R. Cooper

Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection

Melissa A. Z. Knoll

Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection

Dave Sieminski

Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection

David Zimmerman

Independent

Date Written: September 1, 2016

Abstract

We present the results of a large field study exploring consumers’ use of the Reserve “set aside” feature on the American Express (the company) Serve prepaid card. The study aimed to address two key questions: 1) Can certain strategies encourage consumer saving behavior; and 2) Is saving behavior associated with better outcomes for consumers, particularly for low-income and underserved consumers?

To encourage consumer saving behavior, the company tested four strategies in the field to promote savings to prepaid customers who had not previously signed up for the savings feature. The strategies included: 1) encouragement to save via email; 2) encouragement to save via direct mail; 3) promotional incentives; and 4) encouragement to enroll in automatic transfers to the savings feature.

Results from the pilot indicate that, in particular, offering customers a $10 incentive for using the savings feature during a 12-week period was highly effective at encouraging enrollment in the savings feature. Non-zero balances remained relatively constant through the remainder of the year, suggesting that for consumers still using the savings feature, balances generally did not decrease even after the treatment period ended.

The company also surveyed a random sample of study participants nine months postintervention to learn more about a broad range of personal finance topics. Results from the survey showed that participants who were sent an incentive offer as part of the messaging reported statistically significantly less payday loan use compared to those in the control group.

The results emerging from this pilot suggest that incentivizing prepaid card customers to save, and providing an opportunity for them to do so using a savings feature that keeps funds dedicated for saving separate from those used for spending, could provide tangible financial benefits. Consumers in this pilot demonstrated a willingness to take up the savings feature, indicating interest in alternative savings vehicles, and some customers also reported actual changes in their financial behavior.

Note: This is another in an occasional series of publications from the Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection’s Office of Research. These publications are intended to further the Bureau’s objective of providing an evidence-based perspective on consumer financial markets, consumer behavior, and regulations to inform the public discourse.

Suggested Citation

Cooper, Cheryl R. and Knoll, Melissa A. Z. and Sieminski, Dave and Zimmerman, David, Tools for Saving: Using Prepaid Accounts to Set Aside Funds (September 1, 2016). Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection Data Point Series No. 16-1. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3288823

Cheryl R. Cooper

Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection ( email )

United States

Melissa A. Z. Knoll (Contact Author)

Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection ( email )

United States

Dave Sieminski

Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection ( email )

United States
2024359698 (Phone)

David Zimmerman

Independent

No Address Available

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
22
Abstract Views
207
PlumX Metrics