A Sound Taxonomy of Remedies

73 Pages Posted: 28 Jan 2019

See all articles by Timothy S. Kaye

Timothy S. Kaye

Stetson University College of Law

Date Written: 2017

Abstract

Judges and practitioners need recognized categorizations to act as the premises from which reasoned arguments may be developed. The lack of a meaningful taxonomy of remedies is, therefore, a significant impediment to reasoned legal argument. This paper outlines what such a taxonomy should look like.

Replicative remedies exist to vindicate primary rights. We call them “replicative” because they are designed to replicate the very right that they vindicate. They may be maintained against the whole world, and require no proof of harm or wrongdoing.

Substitutionary remedies exist to vindicate secondary rights. But secondary rights differ from primary rights in that they are not themselves worthy of legal protection. Instead they protect legally-recognized interests. When those interests are harmed by someone else's wrongdoing, substitutionary remedies become available to sanction the wrongdoer by providing to the plaintiff a substitute (typically money) for the interest that was violated.

Transformative remedies are quite different. They do not look back at the nature of the rights or interests that require protection, but instead focus on the future with the object of putting the plaintiff in an entirely new position for which the plaintiff's prior rights offer no analog. Unlike replicative and substitutionary remedies, which reflect prior rights, transformative remedies thus generate entirely new, tertiary rights.

This provides the foundation for a sound taxonomy of remedies. It avoids confusing labels, and helps to unpack problems caused by ambiguous terminology. It can both explain the outcomes of past cases and point the way to solutions to new controversies. It is surely time that this taxonomy became more widely articulated and understood.

Keywords: Remedies, Common Law, Equity, Taxonomy, Rights, Wrongs, Not-Wrongs, Powers

Suggested Citation

Kaye, Timothy S., A Sound Taxonomy of Remedies (2017). Quinnipiac Law Review, Vol. 36, 2017, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3316417

Timothy S. Kaye (Contact Author)

Stetson University College of Law ( email )

1401 61st Street South
Gulfport, FL 33707
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
77
Abstract Views
434
rank
385,625
PlumX Metrics