The Place of Equality in Habermas' and Dworkin's Theories of Justice

European Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 3 No. 1, pp. 21-35, 1995

Posted: 7 May 2019

Date Written: 1995

Abstract

There is a longstanding debate within the liberal camp that concerns the best hierarchical ordering of such ideals as liberty, equality. In specifying the egalitarian idea of treating people as equals, should we give priority to liberties (and participation) or to distributional equality? It is this issue with which this paper is concerned. Gosepath regards Habermas' theory as an example for the first route and Dworkin's as an example for the second. In the tradition of Kant, Habermas claims that liberal justice is primarily concerned with rights to basic liberties. For Dworkin, however, the primary liberal ideal is equality, which he sees embodied in equality of resources. All other principles of liberalism, such as equal rights to liberty and political neutrality, follow from this primary ideal. Since Habermas' fundamental principle yields only rights to equal liberty, his theory does not have much to say about distributive justice or equality of distribution. Dworkin, on the other hand, begins with a complex theory of equality of distribution. Habermas and Dworkin thus have very different conceptions with regard to the second concept of equality and distributive justice. In this paper, Gosepath first discusses Habermas’ theory and examine the reasons for the fact that his theory contains no conception of distributional equality (II). Then Gosepath asks whether Dworkin’s theory can offer a better alternative (III). At the end of his critical examination of Habermas and Dworkin, Gosepath sketches very briefly an approach which might be able to avoid the disadvantages of both theories while preserving their advantages (IV).

Suggested Citation

Gosepath, Stefan, The Place of Equality in Habermas' and Dworkin's Theories of Justice (1995). European Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 3 No. 1, pp. 21-35, 1995, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3368882

Stefan Gosepath (Contact Author)

Freie Universität Berlin ( email )

Thielallee 43
Berlin, Berlin 14195
Germany

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
163
PlumX Metrics