An Equality Paradigm for Preventing Genetic Discrimination

54 Pages Posted: 11 Dec 2002

See all articles by Michael Ashley Stein

Michael Ashley Stein

Visiting Professor, Harvard Law School; University of Pretoria Faculty of Law, Centre for Human Rights

Anita Silvers

San Francisco State University - Department of Philosophy

Abstract

In this article we argue for the creation of an equality-based protection similar to that of race and sex discrimination. In doing so, we demonstrate the confluence of genetic discrimination with that of disability discrimination, and discuss some problems inherent with current approaches to statutory protection in both these areas. We show that the ADA, as well as current and proposed genetic discrimination laws, bifurcates the population into protected and unprotected groups. The ADA and specialized genetic discrimination law protect different groups that are, essentially, mirror images of each other while leaving an important part of the population unprotected. In practice the ADA applies only to those individuals who are seriously symptomatic, while genetic discrimination law extends only to those who are either nonsymptomatic or asymptomatic. Falling between these two poles and thus lacking protection is a large group of presymptomatic individuals with genetic anomalies which may never be expressed or, if expressed, may not manifest as unmitigatable functional impairments. Because excluding this latter category of individuals from labor market participation (and attendant social opportunities) is probabilistically unjustifiable as well as enormously costly to society, we advocate their inclusion in the classification of the group targeted for genetic discrimination protection. We also set to rest fears that so broadly extending protection will increase transactional costs for everyone. In making these assertions, this article diverges widely from existing legal scholarship. To date, commentators advocate either for greater application of the ADA or the enactment of specific legislation to the realm of genetic discrimination without either noting or addressing the exclusion from coverage of presymptomatic individuals.

Suggested Citation

Stein, Michael Ashley and Silvers, Anita, An Equality Paradigm for Preventing Genetic Discrimination. Vanderbilt Law Review, Forthcoming. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=337720 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.337720

Michael Ashley Stein (Contact Author)

Visiting Professor, Harvard Law School ( email )

1585 Massachussetts Avenue
Austin Hall 305
Cambridge, MA 02138
United States
617-495-1726 (Phone)

University of Pretoria Faculty of Law, Centre for Human Rights ( email )

Private Bag X20
Hatfield 0028
Pretoria
South Africa

Anita Silvers

San Francisco State University - Department of Philosophy ( email )

1600 Holloway Avenue
San Francisco, CA 94132
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
195
rank
152,702
Abstract Views
1,754
PlumX Metrics
!

Under construction: SSRN citations while be offline until July when we will launch a brand new and improved citations service, check here for more details.

For more information