While They Waited: Pre- Obergefell Lives and the Law of Nonmarriage
Yale Law Journal Forum, Vol. 129, p. 1, July 2019
18 Pages Posted: 3 Aug 2019 Last revised: 20 Sep 2019
Date Written: July 30, 2019
In the wake of Obergefell, the United States now has a large class of married, same-sex couples whose relationships began at a time when marriage was unavailable to them. The law must therefore wrestle with the question whether any portion of a pre-Obergefell relationship should count toward the length of the ensuing marriage — an important question given the number of marital benefits tied directly to this calculation. As courts and legislators alike wrestle with this difficult question, they will need to examine how these couples ordered their relationships during a time when “nonmarriage” was the only option. This Essay argues that such an examination provides a unique opportunity for the law to not only move toward true marriage equality, but also reconsider its overall approach to nonmarriage in general. Specifically, this Essay identifies three lessons that can be gleaned from same-sex couples whose relationships spanned both sides of the marriage equality movement. It argues that each of these lessons can help us craft greater protections for nonmarital relationships.
Keywords: obergefell, same-sex marriage, nonmarriage, cohabitation
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation