Youth Voting Rights and the Unfulfilled Promise of the Twenty-Sixth Amendment

62 Pages Posted: 24 Aug 2019

See all articles by Yael Bromberg

Yael Bromberg

Georgetown University Law Center - Civil Rights Clinic, Voting Rights Institute; Bromberg Law LLC

Date Written: August 1, 2019

Abstract

The Twenty-Sixth Amendment was designed to bring young people into the political process by constitutionalizing their right to vote. However, the last fifty years have shown that ratification has not been enough: the Amendment has remained largely untouched by the courts since the 1970s, even as voter suppression increasingly threatens access to the franchise for students and other young voters.

The handful of courts considering Twenty-Sixth Amendment claims in the modern era have reasoned in dicta that such claims' analysis should be informed by a discriminatory purpose standard, while acknowledging inherent problems with this assumption. Indeed, courts have reflected on the dearth of guidance on how to handle such claims, admittedly stumbling through their analysis and applying only arguably apposite precedent by analogy. I suggest that the searching approach that has evolved is not necessarily wrong, but that it merely sets the floor to evaluating youth voter claims, rather than the ceiling. Instead, this Article proposes a Twenty-Sixth Amendment standard that draws on both modern right-to-vote and equal protection doctrines. In other words, claims arising under the Twenty-Sixth Amendment may benefit from a hybrid test that incorporates prima facie, intentional discrimination, and "right to vote" balancing analyses.

There exists little scholarship on the appropriate framework for evaluating claims that state action unduly abridges the right to vote on account of age as prohibited by the Twenty-Sixth Amendment; this Article thus offers a new way of thinking of the voting rights of this often-forgotten group and proposes a solution for examining future claims on behalf of this class.

Keywords: Constitutional Law; Standard of Review; Youth; Youth Voting; Age; Suspect Class; Fundamental Right; Right to Vote; Twenty-Sixth Amendment; 26th Amendment; Fourteenth Amendment; 14th Amendment

Suggested Citation

Bromberg, Yael, Youth Voting Rights and the Unfulfilled Promise of the Twenty-Sixth Amendment (August 1, 2019). University of Pennsylvania Journal of Constitutional Law, Vol. 21, No. 5, 1105, May 2019. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3442198

Yael Bromberg (Contact Author)

Georgetown University Law Center - Civil Rights Clinic, Voting Rights Institute ( email )

Bromberg Law LLC ( email )

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
84
Abstract Views
553
rank
298,817
PlumX Metrics