Methods and Severity: The Two Tracks of Section 12

Forthcoming 2019, Supreme Court Law Review (2d)

21 Pages Posted: 17 Oct 2019 Last revised: 20 Oct 2019

See all articles by Lisa Kerr

Lisa Kerr

Queen's University - Faculty of Law

Benjamin L. Berger

York University - Osgoode Hall Law School

Date Written: July 1, 2019

Abstract

This paper argues that there are two main routes – two tracks – by which one can arrive at the fundamental wrong at the heart of section 12 of the Charter. On the “methods track”, the state can run afoul of section 12 by using intrinsically unacceptable methods of treatment or punishment. For historical reasons, jurisprudence on this track is not well developed in Canada, though it would clearly prohibit the death penalty and most methods of corporal punishment. On the “severity track”, the concern is with excessive punishment. Here, even where the state has chosen a legitimate method of punishment, like fines or imprisonment, the amount of punishment may be grossly disproportionate in light of factors like the gravity of the offence and the circumstances of the offender. To date, the distinction between the two tracks, and its implications for section 12 analysis, has gone unrecognized in the caselaw and scholarship alike. Carefully drawing this distinction, and identifying the particular inquiry appropriate to each track, not only sharpens our understanding of section 12, but will assist reviewing courts tasked with analyzing the constitutionality of a range of carceral practices, including mandatory penalties, life imprisonment without the prospect of parole, and solitary confinement.

Keywords: criminal law, mandatory minimum sentences, punishment, sentencing, cruel and unusual treatment or punishment

Suggested Citation

Kerr, Lisa and Berger, Benjamin L., Methods and Severity: The Two Tracks of Section 12 (July 1, 2019). Forthcoming 2019, Supreme Court Law Review (2d). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3466354

Lisa Kerr

Queen's University - Faculty of Law ( email )

Macdonald Hall
Kingston, Ontario K7L 3N6 K7L3N6
Canada

Benjamin L. Berger (Contact Author)

York University - Osgoode Hall Law School ( email )

4700 Keele Street
Toronto, Ontario M3J 1P3
Canada

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
59
Abstract Views
268
rank
365,543
PlumX Metrics