The Normative Value of Legal Analytics. Is There a Case for Statistical Precedent?

69 Pages Posted: 4 Nov 2019

See all articles by Geneviève Vanderstichele

Geneviève Vanderstichele

University of Oxford, Faculty of Law, Students; Court of Appeal Ghent (Be)

Date Written: August 30, 2019

Abstract

This work contributes to the harmonisation of the quantitative methodologies of data science, computer science and statistics with the qualitative methodology of the law.

It gives a layered answer to the research question whether the outcome of a machine learning algorithm with case law as an input can have normative value. The thesis argues first that the outcome of a machine learning algorithm with case law as an input is not ‘law’ as we know it today. Neither is it a fact in a court case, nor a secondary source of law. The thesis claims furthermore that for methodological reasons, such an outcome is to be considered as a ‘sui generis’ concept, a concept of its own kind, with which courts can, and even should, engage in adjudication. In addition, it is argued that modelling with machine learning can have an implicit normativity through the definition of the purpose of the algorithm, its design and the choices that are made by the software engineers.

In the first part, the work introduces several building blocks that inform the following parts. The second part is a critical analysis of 9 experiments with mainly supervised machine learning algorithms, with case law as an input. The final part discusses the use of the outcome of such algorithms in court cases.

Keywords: Machine learning, algorithms, adjudication, courts, decision-making, law, precedent, statistical precedent, normative value

JEL Classification: K, C

Suggested Citation

Vanderstichele, Geneviève, The Normative Value of Legal Analytics. Is There a Case for Statistical Precedent? (August 30, 2019). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3474878

Geneviève Vanderstichele (Contact Author)

University of Oxford, Faculty of Law, Students ( email )

St Cross Building
St Cross Rd
Oxford
United Kingdom

Court of Appeal Ghent (Be) ( email )

Belgium

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
97
Abstract Views
425
rank
276,749
PlumX Metrics