IP, the NAP, and Pre-Propertarian Liberty: New-Paradigm Libertarian Replies to some Rothbardian Criticisms
Arguments for Liberty: A Libertarian Miscellany. Buckingham, England: The University of Buckingham Press, pp. 160-183 (2016)
15 Pages Posted: 8 Nov 2019
Date Written: 2016
Andy Curzon replied (often quoting from the opening sections of Lester 2014, chapter 10) in an ongoing debate with Lee Waaks, which Mr Waaks forwarded (with approval) to the Libertarian Alliance Forum (27 February 2015). This response replies to the criticisms after directly quoting them (the indented text; except where Lester is occasionally quoted, as indicated). A few cuts have been made to avoid some repetition and irrelevance. However, just as Mr Curzon sometimes repeats his main points in slightly different ways and contexts in the hope that some of them might prove cogent, so this reply does the same. The dialogue-like result seems to engage more directly and completely than producing a new stand-alone exposition. And some new arguments are even developed in the process. But the full nature of many of the criticisms and replies often only becomes clear as the “dialogue” proceeds. An addendum then rebuts two further brief critical responses in the same manner.
Keywords: intellectual property, non-aggression principle, libertarianism
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation