Too Much, Too Soon? 'Obergefell' as Applied Equality Practice

60 Pages Posted: 12 Nov 2019

See all articles by James M. Donovan

James M. Donovan

University of Kentucky

Alyssa Oakley Milby

affiliation not provided to SSRN

Date Written: November 1, 2018

Abstract

Abrupt cultural change inevitably arouses anxieties, and often those fears provoke a retrograde reaction seeking to preserve the familiar status quo. When the world by which we define ourselves undergoes unexpected transitions, especially in directions that contradict the comfortable taken-for-granted assumptions that had been earlier enjoyed, we feel threatened. One needs only recall how the new standards of racial equality announced in Brown I and Brown II elicited virulent protests as some districts chose to shutter all public schools rather than have them become racially integrated.

In the shadow of such traumas, it may seem an obvious lesson that progress should be slow and incremental, going only so far and as fast as the changes can be absorbed into the social habits. William Eskridge has offered a full-throated defense of modulating the rate of change in order to avoid these unintended consequences of modernization. Legal rights can be formally recognized, he says, but their enforcement should not outpace the acceptance of the new order.

The prudence that Eskridge counsels appeals at an intuitive level, but is too abstract to provide useful guidance on how the real world should behave. This paper attempts to demonstrate a means to distinguish situations when caution is prudent from those when it is not, by examining the context in which Eskridge himself frames his defense of incrementalism, that of same-sex marriage.

This paper attempts to demonstrate a means to distinguish situations when caution is prudent from those when it is not, by examining the context in which Eskridge himself frames his defense of incrementalism, that of same-sex marriage.

Suggested Citation

Donovan, James M. and Milby, Alyssa Oakley, Too Much, Too Soon? 'Obergefell' as Applied Equality Practice (November 1, 2018). Mississippi Law Journal, Vol. 88, Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3479346

James M. Donovan (Contact Author)

University of Kentucky ( email )

J. David Rosenberg College of Law
620 S. Limestone Street
Lexington, KY 40506-0048
United States

Alyssa Oakley Milby

affiliation not provided to SSRN

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
123
Abstract Views
416
Rank
487,243
PlumX Metrics