Patent Rights and Local Working Under the WTO Trips Agreement: An Analysis of the U.S.-Brazil Patent Dispute

29 Pages Posted: 9 Nov 2002

See all articles by Amir Attaran

Amir Attaran

University of Ottawa - Common Law Section; University of Ottawa - Department of Epidemiology and Community Medicine

Paul Champ

Raven, Allen, Cameron & Ballantyne

Abstract

A recent WTO dispute between the United States and Brazil revives an issue that was not definitively resolved in the TRIPS agreement, i.e., the legality of local working requirements for patents. For centuries, states have required patentees to manufacture - or "locally work" - inventions patented in their territory as a means of achieving economic development and technology transfer. In past treaties, countries have agreed to provide compulsory licensing as the remedy for "failure to work". During the TRIPS negotiations, the parties advanced several options for the future of local working provisions. Unfortunately, the final agreement was essentially arbitrated on that issue, and the understanding of the respective parties regarding local working remained unclear.

Ultimately, the Brazil case was settled for political reasons, but the U.S. reserved its right to re-litigate the issue and has warned that it will "aggressively engage" any other countries that seek to utilize local working. Thus, it is inevitable that the legality of local working will continue to be questioned. In this paper, we analyze the historical rationale of local working requirements, the treatment of local working in the travaux preparatoires of TRIPS, and the canon of treaty interpretation, in order to ascertain whether local working is or is not legal under TRIPS. We conclude that it is, and that the interpretation proposed by the U.S. constitutes a significant normative departure from international practice that is unsupported by the text or travaux preparatoires of the TRIPS.

Suggested Citation

Attaran, Amir and Attaran, Amir and Champ, Paul, Patent Rights and Local Working Under the WTO Trips Agreement: An Analysis of the U.S.-Brazil Patent Dispute. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=348660 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.348660

Amir Attaran (Contact Author)

University of Ottawa - Common Law Section ( email )

57 Louis Pasteur Street
Ottawa, K1N 6N5
Canada
613-562-5800 ext: 2015 (Phone)
613-562-5659 (Fax)

University of Ottawa - Department of Epidemiology and Community Medicine ( email )

451 Smyth Road
Ottawa, Ontario K1H 8M5
Canada

Paul Champ

Raven, Allen, Cameron & Ballantyne ( email )

Suite 1600
220 Laurier Avenue
Ottawa, Ontario
Canada

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
1,115
Abstract Views
6,300
Rank
35,954
PlumX Metrics