The Concept of Abuse of Law in European Taxation: A Methodological and Constitutional Perspective

24 Pages Posted: 21 Nov 2019

See all articles by Wolfgang Schoen

Wolfgang Schoen

Max Planck Institute for Tax Law and Public Finance, Department of Business and Tax Law

Date Written: November 20, 2019

Abstract

In two recent cases “T Danmark” and “N Luxembourg 1” the European Court of Justice delivered landmark judgments on the impact of the concept of “abuse of law” in the area of taxation. In these judgments the Court promoted the recurrent notion that “European law cannot be relied up-on for abusive or fraudulent ends” to the rank of a “general principle” of European law in matters of direct taxation. This has a profound effect on the legal framework for taxpayers and tax authorities as such a “general principle” has the power to override both secondary EU law and national tax legislation. According to the Court, it has to be applied irrespective of conflicting provisions in EU tax directives and without any explicit basis under domestic tax law. This article, which has been written to celebrate Professor Judith Freedman on the occasion of her retirement at Oxford University, challenges the findings of the Court, which create confusion and uncertainty both from a methodological and a constitutional perspective. This article proposes to recognize a concept of “abuse of law” at the level of secondary EU law, thus leaving the hierarchy of norms under European law and the interaction between EU law and national legislation intact.

Keywords: Abuse of Law, European Taxation, European Law, European Court of Justice, Direct Taxation

JEL Classification: H26, K33, K34

Suggested Citation

Schön, Wolfgang, The Concept of Abuse of Law in European Taxation: A Methodological and Constitutional Perspective (November 20, 2019). Working Paper of the Max Planck Institute for Tax Law and Public Finance No. 2019-18. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3490489

Wolfgang Schön (Contact Author)

Max Planck Institute for Tax Law and Public Finance, Department of Business and Tax Law ( email )

Marstallplatz 1
Munich, 80539
Germany

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
60
Abstract Views
144
rank
364,831
PlumX Metrics