Credit Union and Bank Subprime Lending in the Great Recession

57 Pages Posted: 23 Dec 2019

See all articles by Jordan van Rijn

Jordan van Rijn

University of Wisconsin - Madison - Agricultural and Applied Economics; Credit Union National Association (CUNA); Center for Financial Security

Kangli Li

University of Wisconsin-Madison; Credit Union National Association

Date Written: December 19, 2019

Abstract

We develop a theoretical model that predicts that credit unions will offer relatively less risky loans (e.g., fewer “subprime” mortgages) compared to similar commercial banks due to credit unions’ focus on member utility as nonprofit financial cooperatives. The model also predicts that banks will increase subprime lending more than credit unions during economic expansions and decrease subprime lending more than credit unions during recessions. We use the financial crisis and Great Recession period of 2007–2009 to test our model and find that, as predicted, commercial banks engaged in approximately five times more subprime lending relative to credit unions during the period leading up to the financial crisis (2003–2006). Banks also had delinquency and charge-off rates that were two to three times higher during and immediately following the crisis. We also find that banks were about two-and-a-half times more likely to fail and were significantly more likely to receive TARP government assistance funds. The results are robust to controlling for important differences between credit unions and banks besides structure and incentives, including asset size, portfolio concentration, market share, earnings, liquidity, leverage, mortgages sold to the secondary market, core deposits, and state-level indicators of economic performance and housing prices. We argue that the findings explain why credit unions often appear more risk averse relative to commercial banks, and hold important implications for researchers, policymakers and regulators.

Keywords: Financial institutions, credit unions, cooperatives, risk management, financial crisis

JEL Classification: G01, G21, G23

Suggested Citation

van Rijn, Jordan and Li, Kangli, Credit Union and Bank Subprime Lending in the Great Recession (December 19, 2019). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3506873 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3506873

Jordan Van Rijn (Contact Author)

University of Wisconsin - Madison - Agricultural and Applied Economics ( email )

427 Lorch St.
Madison, WI 53706
United States

HOME PAGE: http://https://aae.wisc.edu/staff/vanrijn/

Credit Union National Association (CUNA) ( email )

5710 Mineral Point Rd
Madison, WI 53705
United States
6082153896 (Phone)

HOME PAGE: http://https://www.cuna.org/CUNA-Research-and-Policy-Analysis-Team/Jordan-van-Rijn/?EventID=23622406

Center for Financial Security ( email )

Madison, WI
United States

HOME PAGE: http://https://cfs.wisc.edu/2018/09/26/jordan-van-rijn/

Kangli Li

University of Wisconsin-Madison ( email )

426 Lorch Ct
Madison, WI 53705
United States

Credit Union National Association ( email )

5710 Mineral Point Rd
Madison, WI 53705
United States

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
82
Abstract Views
703
rank
337,160
PlumX Metrics