Pronouncements of Expert Treaty Bodies: From ‘Black Boxes’ to ‘Key Catalysts’ in International Law?

KFG Working Paper Series, No. 40, Berlin Potsdam Research Group “The International Rule of Law – Rise or Decline?”

26 Pages Posted: 10 Jan 2020 Last revised: 14 Jan 2020

See all articles by Janina Barkholdt

Janina Barkholdt

Humboldt University of Berlin

Nina Reiners

affiliation not provided to SSRN

Date Written: December 1, 2019

Abstract

While some pronouncements of expert treaty bodies have been considered ‘key catalysts’ for the development of international human rights law, others are only selectively referred to in legal practice. This article argues that the varying normative impact is due to the informal character of pronouncements. In the absence of treaty provisions specifying their legal effect, practitioners tend to rely on different factors and arguments when either drawing on or rejecting certain pronouncements. Scholars in turn face difficulties when trying to identify explanatory patterns within this diverging practice as the informal character confronts both international lawyers and international relations scholars with their respective methodological ‘blind spots’. In light of these intradisciplinary challenges, this article explores the extent as to which an interdisciplinary approach helps to assess the reasons for the varying impact of pronouncements. After analysing the factors determining their legal significance on the basis of State practice and the academic debate, this article identifies the drafting process as a factor which promises to be particularly insightful when explored from an interdisciplinary perspective and sketches out a framework for future research.

Suggested Citation

Barkholdt, Janina and Reiners, Nina, Pronouncements of Expert Treaty Bodies: From ‘Black Boxes’ to ‘Key Catalysts’ in International Law? (December 1, 2019). KFG Working Paper Series, No. 40, Berlin Potsdam Research Group “The International Rule of Law – Rise or Decline?”. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3507386 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3507386

Janina Barkholdt (Contact Author)

Humboldt University of Berlin ( email )

Unter den Linden 6
Berlin, Berlin 10099
Germany

Nina Reiners

affiliation not provided to SSRN

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
38
Abstract Views
184
PlumX Metrics