The Three Permissions: Presidential Removal and the Statutory Limits of Agency Independence

81 Pages Posted: 25 Feb 2020 Last revised: 10 Nov 2020

See all articles by Jane Manners

Jane Manners

Columbia Law School

Lev Menand

Columbia Law School

Date Written: February 16, 2020

Abstract

Seven words stand between the President and the heads of over a dozen "independent" agencies: inefficiency, neglect of duty, and malfeasance in office (INM). The President can remove the heads of these agencies for INM and INM only. But neither Congress nor the courts have defined INM and hence the extent of agency independence. Some proponents of presidential power argue that INM allows the President to dismiss officials who do not follow presidential directives. Others contend that INM is unconstitutional because it prevents presidents from fulfilling their constitutional duty to take care that the laws are faithfully executed. This Article recovers the lost history of INM, explaining its origins and meaning, inverting our current understanding of removal law, and rejecting both challenges to agency independence. It shows that INM provisions are not removal “protections” that prevent at-pleasure removal; they are removal permissions that authorize removal where it is otherwise prohibited by an officer’s term of years, a tenure long understood to bar executive removal for any reason. INM provisions are narrow exceptions to term tenures: Neglect of duty and malfeasance in office cash out an official’s failure to faithfully execute official duties, while inefficiency relates to government waste and ineptitude. INM provisions do not permit the President to remove agency heads for failing to follow presidential directives. But they do not clash with the Take Care Clause either, because even on an expansive reading of the clause, INM provisions authorize presidents to remove unfaithful or incompetent officials.

Keywords: Administrative Law, Constitutional Law, Independent Agencies, Removal Law, Legal History, Legal Theory

JEL Classification: K10

Suggested Citation

Manners, Jane and Menand, Lev, The Three Permissions: Presidential Removal and the Statutory Limits of Agency Independence (February 16, 2020). 121 Columbia Law Review, Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3520377 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3520377

Jane Manners

Columbia Law School ( email )

435 W 116th St.
New York, NY 10027
United States

Lev Menand (Contact Author)

Columbia Law School ( email )

435 West 116th Street
New York, NY 10025
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
277
Abstract Views
2,115
rank
132,948
PlumX Metrics