The Plenary Power Meets the Police Power: Federalism at the Intersection of Health & Immigration

American Journal of Law & Medicine, Vol. 45, pp. 224-246 (2019)

Northeastern University School of Law Research Paper No. 268-2020

25 Pages Posted: 8 Feb 2020

See all articles by Wendy E. Parmet

Wendy E. Parmet

Northeastern University - School of Law

Date Written: January 23, 2020

Abstract

The regulation of immigration has traditionally been considered an exclusive federal function, over which the elected branches have so-called plenary power. In contrast, the protection of public health has long been viewed as falling primarily within the purview of the states’ police power. These two long-standing, but never fully followed, tenets of federalism are increasingly in tension as so-called Blue States seek to expand non-citizens’ access to health benefits, while the Trump Administration institutes a series of immigration restrictions that will deter non-citizens from utilizing health benefits or accessing health care. This paper explores this tension, focusing in particular on the federalism implications of the Administration’s public charge rule. Part One of the paper discusses the doctrinal foundations for the federal government’s exclusive and plenary power over immigration, as well as the state’s primary responsibility over health. Part Two problematizes the notion of separate spheres, and looks at the overlapping and contested relationship between the federal government and the states with respect to immigration, health, and especially immigration policies that relate to health. Part Three discusses the values, including self-governance, accountability, and separation of powers, that are salient to determining the appropriate scope of federal and state action at the intersection between health and immigration. The paper concludes by arguing that these values, as well as a regard for public health, should lead courts to reject an expansive application of the plenary power doctrine when a President’s immigration initiatives impede state health policies.

Keywords: health, immigration, police power

Suggested Citation

Parmet, Wendy E., The Plenary Power Meets the Police Power: Federalism at the Intersection of Health & Immigration (January 23, 2020). American Journal of Law & Medicine, Vol. 45, pp. 224-246 (2019); Northeastern University School of Law Research Paper No. 268-2020. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3524534 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3524534

Wendy E. Parmet (Contact Author)

Northeastern University - School of Law ( email )

416 Huntington Avenue
Boston, MA 02115
United States
(617) 373-2019 (Phone)
(617) 373-5056 (Fax)

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
24
Abstract Views
169
PlumX Metrics