The Puzzle of the Constitutional Home

51 Pages Posted: 12 Feb 2020

See all articles by Gerald S. Dickinson

Gerald S. Dickinson

University of Pittsburgh - School of Law

Date Written: February 10, 2020

Abstract

The home enjoys a special place in American constitutional law. A doctrinal thread runs across the first five amendments that demarcates the home as a realm in which rights enjoy elevated protection. That thread covers rights involving smut, guns, soldiers, searches, and self-incrimination, but inexplicably does not extend to takings. This stark dichotomy between the solicitude of the home for most rights and the opposite for takings produces a deep puzzle.

This Article contends that the answer to this fundamental puzzle is that the Court’s takings doctrine, unlike the home-centric doctrines in the Bill of Rights, is infected with post-Lochner v. New York judicial deference to economic regulation. This has influenced the Court’s aversion to a special protections doctrine to homes under the Takings Clause. This Article argues that, as a matter of constitutional coherence theory, which prizes doctrinal symmetry and harmony, the Court should, in limited circumstances, extend the home-centric thread to protect homes in takings that expropriate title to or impact the economic value of homes.

This Article also grapples with several broader methodological, doctrinal, and theoretical implications. First, the Court consistently applies atextual methods of interpretation of the home. Second, this atextual interpretive pattern of influence supports this Article’s proposition that the home-centric doctrinal thread should extend to takings. Finally, a congruent home-centric Bill of Rights that extends to takings aligns neatly with constitutional coherence theory.

Keywords: State Constitutional Law, Takings, Supreme Court, Zoning, General Welfare, Federalism, Constitutional Property, Takings, Kelo, Constitutional Law, Fifth Amendment, Regulatory Takings

JEL Classification: K11, K19, R38, R52

Suggested Citation

Dickinson, Gerald S., The Puzzle of the Constitutional Home (February 10, 2020). Ohio State Law Journal, Vol. 80, p. 1099, 2019, U. of Pittsburgh Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2020-04, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3535762

Gerald S. Dickinson (Contact Author)

University of Pittsburgh - School of Law ( email )

3900 Forbes Ave.
Pittsburgh, PA 15260
United States
412 328 3198 (Phone)

HOME PAGE: http://law.pitt.edu/people/gerald-s-dickinson

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
55
Abstract Views
701
Rank
710,501
PlumX Metrics