D.C. Circuit Upholds IRS’s Voluntary Regulation of Tax Preparers — Majority Holds APA’s Statutory Notice and Comment Not Required: AICPA V. IRS

15 N.Y.U. J. L. & Bus. 229 (2019)

Pace University Research Paper

27 Pages Posted: 20 Feb 2020

Date Written: Spring 2019

Abstract

In American Institute of Certified Public Accountants v. Internal Revenue Service, the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the District Court’s dismissal and held, for the second time, that the AICPA had standing to challenge the IRS’s Annual Filing Season Program – a voluntary program to regulate tax return preparers. The D.C. Circuit went a step further and, instead of remand, ruled on the merits of the AICPA’s challenge. It upheld the IRS’s authority to promulgate the voluntary program to enhance the skills of licensed tax return preparers. While the D.C. Circuit was unanimous on the standing issue and the merits of the challenge, it split two-to-one on whether the IRS had followed proper procedure when it adopted the AFSP without first providing the requisite “notice and comment” period required by the Administrative Procedures Act.

This Article analyzes three critical issues from the decision: standing, the merits of the challenge, and the dissent’s contention that the APA requires notice and comment for this rulemaking. The article concludes that the dissents analysis is APA is compelling and the IRS should have not have bypassed the notice and comment period in promulgating the AFSP. Despite the unanimous holding on the merits, that glaring procedural defect warranted the critical remedy of remand and vacatur. Without it, future IRS rulemaking may be guided by the “no harm, no foul” mindset and result in an unfortunate erosion of the due process protections of the APA.

Keywords: Taxation, APA Notice & Comment, IRS, Competitor Standing

Suggested Citation

Colella, Frank G., D.C. Circuit Upholds IRS’s Voluntary Regulation of Tax Preparers — Majority Holds APA’s Statutory Notice and Comment Not Required: AICPA V. IRS (Spring 2019). 15 N.Y.U. J. L. & Bus. 229 (2019), Pace University Research Paper, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3539557

Frank G. Colella (Contact Author)

Pace University ( email )

One Pace Plaza
New York, NY 10038-1502
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
39
Abstract Views
332
PlumX Metrics