Constructing a Constitutional Right: Borrowing and Second Amendment Design Choices

47 Pages Posted: 10 Mar 2020 Last revised: 19 Feb 2021

See all articles by Jacob D. Charles

Jacob D. Charles

Pepperdine University - Rick J. Caruso School of Law

Date Written: February 18, 2020

Abstract

In fleshing out the contours of the nascent Second Amendment right, both courts and commentators have looked to established constitutional rights for guidance. Many, for example, have imported the analytical scaffolding of the First Amendment, including its heightened protection for “core” constitutional conduct and measured review for regulations akin to “time, place, and manner” restrictions. Others have lifted the “undue burden” test from its context in reproductive-autonomy jurisprudence to assess the burden a law imposes on the right to keep and carry firearms. Still others have found a parallel in the historical inquiry required to evaluate claims under the Seventh Amendment.

Drawing on the concept of constitutional borrowing, this Article is the first to systematically trace these links between the Second Amendment and other constitutional rights. It explores the sources from which Second Amendment cases and commentators borrow, and why they do so. And, after tracing these links, the Article explains how we should evaluate these instances of borrowing the same way we evaluate other types of analogical reasoning in law: by whether they are grounded in relevant similarities. Finally, the Article argues that current borrowing in Second Amendment jurisprudence falls short in two ways and then sketches a path forward. First, it ought to pay more attention to the theoretical underpinnings for the right to keep and bear arms; and second, the practice ought to pay more attention to the reasons why some elements should be borrowed from one rights domain while others should be rejected.

Keywords: Second Amendment, constitutional borrowing

Suggested Citation

Charles, Jacob D., Constructing a Constitutional Right: Borrowing and Second Amendment Design Choices (February 18, 2020). 99 North Carolina Law Review 333 (2021), Duke Law School Public Law & Legal Theory Series No. 2020-9, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3539883

Jacob D. Charles (Contact Author)

Pepperdine University - Rick J. Caruso School of Law ( email )

24255 Pacific Coast Highway
Malibu, CA 90263
United States

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
149
Abstract Views
1,254
Rank
358,229
PlumX Metrics