RATIONING AND DISABILITY: THE CIVIL RIGHTS AND WRONGS OF STATE TRIAGE PROTOCOLS

67 Pages Posted: 7 Apr 2020 Last revised: 4 Feb 2021

See all articles by Deborah Hellman

Deborah Hellman

University of Virginia School of Law

Kate Nicholson

Independent

Date Written: February 4, 2021

Abstract

The COVID-19 pandemic and the unprecedented natural disasters of 2020 remind us of the importance of emergency preparedness. This Article contributes to our legal and ethical readiness by examining state “Crisis Standards of Care,” which are the standards that determine how medical resources are allocated in times of scarcity. The Article identifies a flaw in the policy choice at the heart of the standards: the standards focus on saving as many lives as possible, but, in so doing, will predictably disadvantage the ability of people with disabilities and racial minorities to access life-saving care.

To date, scholarly attention has focused on explicit exclusions of people with particular medical conditions or the standards’ failure to be sufficiently individualized. Amending the protocols to address these concerns, while important, will simply tinker at the margins. The more consequential and harder question is how states should balance the demand to save as many lives as possible, while also ensuring that people with disabilities and other vulnerable groups are treated fairly.

To answer that question, the authors distill and analyze four rationing principles that animate the state standards and contend that none ultimately balances these two important aims in a manner consistent with the Americans With Disabilities Act [ADA] and the moral commitments on which it rests. The Article thus provides a moral and legal framework to guide revision of the standards, which is ongoing. It concludes by proposing a novel, alternative rationing system that reserves resources to accommodate both efficiency and equity, thereby better instantiating the balance that undergirds the ADA.

Keywords: Covid-19, Disability, Rationing, Health care, Discrimination, Disparate Impact

Suggested Citation

Hellman, Deborah and Nicholson, Kate, RATIONING AND DISABILITY: THE CIVIL RIGHTS AND WRONGS OF STATE TRIAGE PROTOCOLS (February 4, 2021). Virginia Public Law and Legal Theory Research Paper No. 2020-33, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3570088

Deborah Hellman (Contact Author)

University of Virginia School of Law ( email )

580 Massie Road
Charlottesville, VA 22903
United States

Kate Nicholson

Independent ( email )

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
955
Abstract Views
3,386
rank
27,658
PlumX Metrics