Breaking Ranks (and Precedent): Reference re Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act, 2020 ABCA 74

(2020) 33(2) J. Env. L. & Practice (Forthcoming)

22 Pages Posted: 19 May 2020

See all articles by Martin Olszynski

Martin Olszynski

University of Calgary - Faculty of Law

Nigel Bankes

University of Calgary - Faculty of Law; University of Tromso - Faculty of Law

Andrew Leach

University of Alberta - Department of Marketing, Business Economics & Law

Date Written: April 21, 2020

Abstract

The Alberta Court of Appeal recently released its decision in Reference re Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act, Alberta’s challenge to the constitutionality of the federal government’s Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act. Writing for a majority of three judges, Chief Justice Catherine Fraser concluded that the GGPPA could not be upheld on the basis of Parliament’s residual power over matters of “peace, order, and good government” (POGG), nor any other potentially relevant federal head of power. This comment focuses on the majority opinion of the Alberta Court of Appeal, beginning with a summary and some brief commentary (Part II). Part III offers detailed commentary on the majority’s approach to section 92A, subsidiarity, the division of powers analysis generally, several aspects of the national concern doctrine, and the overall tenor of the decision. While we acknowledge that there is some uncertainty in the case law that leaves room for genuine disagreement and arguments both for and against the federal government’s reliance on POGG, in our respectful view the majority is simply incorrect on several fronts and strays far from precedent on others. The judgment is also unhelpfully burdened with rhetoric and value judgments that are hardly relevant to the process of legal reasoning.

Keywords: environmental law, climate change, pollution pricing, constitutional law

Suggested Citation

Olszynski, Martin Z.P. and Bankes, Nigel and Leach, Andrew, Breaking Ranks (and Precedent): Reference re Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act, 2020 ABCA 74 (April 21, 2020). (2020) 33(2) J. Env. L. & Practice (Forthcoming), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3581893

Martin Z.P. Olszynski (Contact Author)

University of Calgary - Faculty of Law ( email )

Murray Fraser Hall
2500 University Dr. N.W.
Calgary, Alberta T2N 1N4
Canada

Nigel Bankes

University of Calgary - Faculty of Law ( email )

Murray Fraser Hall
2500 University Dr. N.W.
Calgary, Alberta T2N 1N4
Canada

University of Tromso - Faculty of Law ( email )

Tromsø, 9037
Norway

Andrew Leach

University of Alberta - Department of Marketing, Business Economics & Law ( email )

Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2R6
Canada

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
126
Abstract Views
744
rank
305,603
PlumX Metrics