Revisiting a Classic Problem in Statutory Interpretation: Is a Minister a Laborer?

44 Pages Posted: 28 May 2020 Last revised: 7 Dec 2020

Date Written: April 29, 2020

Abstract

This study presents a new analysis of an iconic United States Supreme Court case, Holy Trinity Church v. United States (1892). The question in Holy Trinity Church concerned whether a law making it illegal to pay the transportation of a person entering the U.S. under contract to perform “labor or service of any kind” applied to a wealthy Manhattan church that had paid to bring its new rector from England to New York. The Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the law did not apply to the church’s contract, relying first on the ordinary meaning of “labor” and second on the legislative history of the single construction “labor or service.”

Highlighting the use of corpus linguistic methods, this study tests the arguments presented by the Court and reveals new insights through an analysis of historic and contemporary reference corpora and a specialized corpus of U.S. statutes. The results demonstrate that the disjunctive phrase labor or service appeared to be a legal term of art with narrow interpretation that would exclude clergy, but around the time of Holy Trinity Church, slight variations on the phrase (e.g., pluralization, conjunction, and modification) applied to contexts with broader meaning. When examining “labor” as an independent term, those who labored were generally not clergy and the description of the activities of clergy was typically not described as labor, although examination evidenced instances of both. The findings demonstrate the importance of consulting corpora in the evaluation of statutory and ordinary meaning and considering the socio-historical contexts in which it occurs.

Keywords: Statutory Interpretation, Corpus Linguistics, Constitution, Labor, Holy Trinity Church

JEL Classification: K14, K31

Suggested Citation

Gales, Tammy and Solan, Lawrence M., Revisiting a Classic Problem in Statutory Interpretation: Is a Minister a Laborer? (April 29, 2020). Georgia State University Law Review, Vol. 36, p. 491, 2020, Brooklyn Law School, Legal Studies Paper, No. 652, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3588805

Tammy Gales

Hofstra University ( email )

Hempstead, NY 11549
United States

Lawrence M. Solan (Contact Author)

Brooklyn Law School ( email )

250 Joralemon Street
Brooklyn, NY 11201
United States
718-780-0357 (Phone)

HOME PAGE: http://www.brooklaw.edu/lawrence_solan

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
70
Abstract Views
318
rank
380,200
PlumX Metrics