Calibrating Macroprudential Policies for the Canadian Mortgage Market

28 Pages Posted: 4 May 2020

See all articles by Scott A. Brave

Scott A. Brave

Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago

Jeremy Kronick

C.D. Howe Institute

Jose A. Lopez

Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco

Date Written: April 30, 2020

Abstract

Macroprudential regulation has been on the rise since the 2007–09 global financial crisis. In Canada, the primary policy tools that have been employed in this regard are related to the residential housing market – namely, changes in mortgage loan-to-value ratios and loan maturity requirements. In this Commentary, we use an analytical model to forecast the probability of a state of low financial stability in the Canadian economy and recommend when policy action might be taken in light of its costs and benefits. We project a low probability of low financial stability in Canada that rises gradually through year-end 2020, but remains low. This might seem odd given recent events around COVID-19. However, there are two things for readers to keep in mind. First, COVID-19 is a black swan event occurring in the real economy, one that does not originate in financial markets, making it difficult for financial regulators and policymakers to anticipate and model in advance. This is critical, as the goal of our paper is to provide a modeling tool to do just that. Second, once we have entered a downturn, financial regulators will not tighten a policy to head off financial instability. They will, in fact, do the opposite, by loosening policy rules to try and stimulate the economy. Canada is an interesting case with respect to financial stability concerns and policies. Although the Canadian economy was able to stave off many of the negative effects of the last financial crisis, it continues to have growing levels of household debt. As a result, after loosening housing-related macroprudential policies in the lead-up to the crisis, policymakers have spent much of the past decade tightening these same policies. Despite work analyzing the effects of housing-related macroprudential policies, there has been very little focus on advising policymakers about when to implement them. Any such advice naturally begins with identifying occasions when financial stability concerns are prominent and likely to remain so, which we refer to as “low financial stability states.” The model identifies three such episodes in Canada between 1990 and the middle of 2019: the early 1990s recession, the mid-1990s government budget rebalancing and the 2008 financial crisis. The four Financial Stability Indicators (FSIs) in our model specifications are the house-priceto-rent ratio, the price-to-income ratio, the debt-servicing ratio and the household-credit-to-GDP ratio. We then use the model to forecast the probability of entering another such episode over a two-year policy horizon. The model provides an answer to the question of whether the probability of entering and staying in a low financial stability state is high enough to go ahead with the policy, given the cost of implementation. Our analysis suggests that, as of the second quarter of 2019, and abstracting from the black swan COVID-19 event, the probability of a lengthy period of low financial stability is low, extending to late 2020.

Keywords: Financial Services and Regulation; Monetary Policy

JEL Classification: E32; G18; G28

Suggested Citation

Brave, Scott A. and Kronick, Jeremy and Lopez, Jose Antonio, Calibrating Macroprudential Policies for the Canadian Mortgage Market (April 30, 2020). C.D. Howe Institute Commentary 570 (2020), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3590324

Scott A. Brave

Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago ( email )

230 South LaSalle Street
Chicago, IL 60604
United States

Jeremy Kronick (Contact Author)

C.D. Howe Institute ( email )

67 Yonge St., Suite 300
Toronto, Ontario M5E 1J8
Canada

Jose Antonio Lopez

Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco ( email )

101 Market Street
San Francisco, CA 94105
United States
415-977-3894 (Phone)
415-974-2168 (Fax)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
28
Abstract Views
253
PlumX Metrics