The Curious Case of Black Conservatives: Construct Validity and the 7-point Liberal-Conservative Scale
41 Pages Posted: 10 Jun 2020 Last revised: 14 Jan 2021
Date Written: July 6, 2020
Abstract
Scholars have long puzzled over the existence of conservative-identifying black Americans who nonetheless identify with and vote for the Democratic Party. This paper resolves this paradox. Leveraging data from the American National Election Study, I demonstrate that the terms “liberal” and “conservative” are unfamiliar to many black Americans, rendering the commonly used 7-point liberal-conservative measure of ideology invalid for this population. Black respondents unfamiliar with these terms misapply them and choose ideological labels that fail to reflect their partisan preferences. Consequently, scholars and political actors make incorrect and imprecise inferences about the contours of black politics in the United States. Moreover, this article raises new concerns about the generalizability of claims that rely on ideological self-identification measures, including popular claims about polarization among the mass public. This work also suggests a need for caution when using concepts that vary in their meaningfulness across social groups.
Keywords: Ideology, Ideological Identification, Black Conservatives, Black Politics, Partisanship, Survey Methodology
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation