Judicial Independence Under Threat: The Court of Justice to the Rescue

Common Market Law Review 55 (6) 1827-1854

19 Pages Posted: 16 Jun 2020

See all articles by Laurent Pech

Laurent Pech

Middlesex University - School of Law

Sébastien Platon

University of Bordeaux - Montesquieu University - Bordeaux IV

Date Written: October 1, 2018

Abstract

The ruling in Associação Sindical dos Juízes Portugueses, often informally referred to as “the Portuguese case”, may be viewed as the Court’s first significant albeit indirect answer to the worrying and ongoing process of ‘rule of law backsliding’ first witnessed in Hungary and now under way in Poland. Indeed, this judgment essentially establishes a general obligation for Member States to guarantee and respect the independence of their national courts and tribunals. What is particularly noteworthy is that the Court has done this solely based on Article 19(1) TEU read in light of Articles 2 and 4(3) TEU.

For those who take Article 2 TEU seriously, Associação Sindical dos Juízes Portugueses offers a silver lining. The Court’s operationalisation of Article 19(1) TEU, while compelling and welcome, is not however bullet-proof. By making inter alia the specific targeting of judges part of its test to decide when one may directly raise a violation of the EU principle of judicial independence via Article 19(1) TEU, the Court leaves however open one possible option for autocratic governments to annihilate judicial independence without activating Article 19(1): the option to act against all checks and balances simultaneously, for instance, by cutting their budgets all at once so that the judiciary is not singled out. The explicit and powerful recognition of the national judiciary as the institution that guarantees the enforcement EU law in all but a few atypical cases, and so that its general health and independence must be a matter of EU concern and not impossible to challenge directly on the basis of EU law, is however to be praised.

Keywords: Rule of Law, Judicial Independence, European Union

Suggested Citation

Pech, Laurent and Platon, Sébastien, Judicial Independence Under Threat: The Court of Justice to the Rescue (October 1, 2018). Common Market Law Review 55 (6) 1827-1854, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3607788

Laurent Pech (Contact Author)

Middlesex University - School of Law ( email )

The Burroughs
WG 11
London, NW4 4BT
United Kingdom

Sébastien Platon

University of Bordeaux - Montesquieu University - Bordeaux IV ( email )

33608 Pessac Cedex
France

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
67
Abstract Views
279
rank
429,070
PlumX Metrics