Does Floor Trading Matter?

Abstract

While algorithmic trading now dominates financial markets, some exchanges continue to use human floor traders. On March 23, 2020 the NYSE suspended floor trading because of COVID-19. Using a difference-in-differences analysis, we find that floor traders are important contributors to market quality. The suspension of floor trading leads to higher effective and quoted spreads and larger pricing errors for treated stocks, relative to control stocks. Moreover, consistent with theoretical predictions about automation, the effects are strongest around the opening and closing auctions when complexity is highest. Our findings suggest that human expertise can complement algorithms in complex situations.

Keywords: Algorithmic trading, DMM, human trading, floor trading, liquidity, market making, market quality, price efficiency

JEL Classification: G12, G14