What Role for the State? (And a Comment on the Common Good)

Australasian Journal of Legal Philosophy, Vol. 44, 2019

9 Pages Posted: 20 Jun 2020

Date Written: 2019


In his "Natural Law and the Nature of Law", Jonathan Crowe has written an important and interesting book, one that should be read by people interested in jurisprudence, ethics, and political philosophy. Its distinctive strength is in the way Crowe shows how much can be done within a natural law framework that does not assume a theological background. A distinctive feature of Crowe's approach to natural law, one that distinguishes it from other well-known approaches, is its argument that only a minimal state, if any state at all, is required by or even compatible with natural law. It is this claim that I focus on in this paper. I show that these anti-state arguments do not work, and that a much more robust, largely state-like, type of political society is necessary if the requirements of natural law that Crowe accepts are to be met. In doing this, I also draw some related conclusions about the proper understanding and reach of the common good. In arguing for this conclusion I do not attack Crowe's general approach, but rather make what I hope to be an internal critique of the argument. If I am successful in this, then there will be reason for people who are sympathetic to the overall project to reject some of Crowe’s sub-conclusions, even if they wish to remain working in the natural law tradition overall. And, there will be reason to accept that something like the modern state will be necessary - at least for some time and for people like us - if we are to live good lives.

Keywords: Natural Law, Jurisprudence, Political Authority, Legal Authority, Philosophy of Law, Common Good, Public Goods, Role of the State, State Authority, Natural Rights, Philosophy of Law

JEL Classification: H41, H42

Suggested Citation

Lister, Matthew J., What Role for the State? (And a Comment on the Common Good) (2019). Australasian Journal of Legal Philosophy, Vol. 44, 2019 , Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3609910

Matthew J. Lister (Contact Author)

Deakin University School of Law ( email )

221 Burwood Highway
Building BC, 6th Floor
Burwood, Victoria 3125

HOME PAGE: http://www.deakin.edu.au/law

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
PlumX Metrics