Whither Judicial Dialogue after Convergence? Finding Transnational Public Law in Nomos-Building

International Journal of Constitutional Law, Forthcoming

32 Pages Posted: 24 Jun 2020

See all articles by Ming-Sung Kuo

Ming-Sung Kuo

University of Warwick - School of Law

Date Written: May 29, 2020

Abstract

One of the major themes emerging from the reinvigorated interest in legal comparativism in the burgeoning transnational legal phenomena is the transnational dialogue among judiciaries the world over, namely, the mutual referencing to judicial decisions across jurisdictional boundaries. This paper aims to rethink the role of transnational judicial dialogue in the development of transnational public law by drawing upon Robert Cover’s discussion of the relationship between nomos and narratives. It is argued that the convergent legal doctrines and principles channeled through transnational judicial dialogue are ‘jurispathic’ as they only generate ‘thin’ transnational values with little power of persuasion. To contribute to the thriving of transnational public law, judicial dialogue should look beyond comparative constitutional jurisprudence, shifting the focus away from the convergence of constitutional doctrines to the building of a transnational nomos. By moving from the mutual learning of doctrines to the comparative articulation of nomos-making narratives — the way a specific doctrine or a legal principle is understood and gains its meaning in its legal culture — in transnational judicial dialogue, comparative constitutional law can enable a robust transnational public law enriched with meanings, which hold the key to persuasion.

Keywords: Judicial Dialogue, Transnational Jurisgenesis, Nomos and Narratives, Transnational Public Law, Law and Community, General Principles of Law, Proportionality Analysis, Transnational Epistemic Community, Persuasion, Judicial Reasoning

Suggested Citation

Kuo, Ming-Sung, Whither Judicial Dialogue after Convergence? Finding Transnational Public Law in Nomos-Building (May 29, 2020). International Journal of Constitutional Law, Forthcoming. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3614137

Ming-Sung Kuo (Contact Author)

University of Warwick - School of Law ( email )

Gibbet Hill Road
Coventry, CV4 7AL
United Kingdom

HOME PAGE: http://warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/law/people?id=4945a0b0c6550cc21bbcc89cf0b570af

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
27
Abstract Views
119
PlumX Metrics