Gideon in the Desert: An Empirical Study of Providing Counsel to Criminal Defendants in Rural Places

29 Pages Posted: 29 Jun 2020

See all articles by Andrew Davies

Andrew Davies

Southern Methodist University – Dedman School of Law

Alyssa Clark

Independent

Date Written: July 1, 2019

Abstract

Access to counsel for criminal defendants is a continuing challenge in rural localities, notwithstanding the mandates of Sixth Amendment jurisprudence. In this Article, we first review the state of the law on access to counsel in criminal cases, noting the latitude allowed to state and local governments in their policy decisions. We then examine empirical approaches to measuring access to counsel and describe in detail both the law and the data on this issue from the state of Texas. We present exploratory analyses of those data comparing rural and urban places for various aspects of access to counsel, including rules governing eligibility for, and rates of actual use of, appointed attorneys. We find that Texas counties appointed counsel to an average of 29% of misdemeanor defendants in 2016-17, but that rates were significantly lower in rural than urban counties. Total expenditures averaged $278 per case, though 8% of that amount was recouped from defendants. In rural areas specifically, we find the absence of any local towns and low lawyer populations were associated with especially low levels of access to counsel. The presence of an organized defense provider such as a public defender office, however, was associated with significantly higher rates of access to counsel in counties. Finally, we review our findings in the light of other research on the impact of programs targeting rural areas intended to improve access to counsel for defendants.

Keywords: counsel, rural, Texas, indigent defense

Suggested Citation

Davies, Andrew and Clark, Alyssa, Gideon in the Desert: An Empirical Study of Providing Counsel to Criminal Defendants in Rural Places (July 1, 2019). Andrew Davies and Alyssa Clark, (2019) “Gideon in the Desert: Providing Counsel to Criminal Defendants in Rural Places.” 71(2) Maine Law Review 245-272., Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3619165

Andrew Davies (Contact Author)

Southern Methodist University – Dedman School of Law ( email )

SMU Dedman School of Law
PO Box 750116
Dallas, TX 75275
United States

Alyssa Clark

Independent

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
28
Abstract Views
280
PlumX Metrics