The Emerging Lessons of Trump v. Hawaii

34 Pages Posted: 14 Jul 2020 Last revised: 1 Sep 2020

Date Written: June 1, 2020

Abstract

In the years since the Supreme Court decided Trump v. Hawaii, federal district courts have adjudicated dozens of rights-based challenges to executive action in immigration law. Plaintiffs, including U.S. citizens, civil rights organizations, and immigrants themselves, have alleged violations of the First Amendment and the equal protection component of the Due Process Clause with some regularity based on the President’s animus toward immigrants. This Essay assesses Hawaii’s impact on these challenges to immigration policy, and it offers two observations. First, Hawaii has amplified federal courts’ practice of privileging administrative law claims over constitutional ones. For example, courts considering separate challenges to the travel ban waiver process and the mass-rescission of humanitarian parole concluded that plaintiffs had not stated constitutional claims under Hawaii’s “circumscribed inquiry,” but these courts remained receptive to plaintiffs’ claims that an agency violated its obligation to provide a reasoned justification, consider reliance interests, explain itself sufficiently, or follow its own procedures. Second, Hawaii has prompted district courts to engage more deeply with the notion that different classes of immigrants are entitled to different levels of constitutional protection. This more open discussion of the contours of immigrants’ rights is a welcome development but ultimately exposes the limits of a rights-based approach to protecting immigrants’ well-being.

Keywords: Trump v. Hawaii, Kleindienst v. Mandel, equal protection, due process, animus, arbitrary and capricious

Suggested Citation

Bhargava Ray, Shalini, The Emerging Lessons of Trump v. Hawaii (June 1, 2020). 29 William & Mary Bill of Rights Journal, Forthcoming 2021, U of Alabama Legal Studies Research Paper No. 3632485, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3632485

Shalini Bhargava Ray (Contact Author)

University of Alabama School of Law ( email )

101 Paul W. Bryant Dr.
Tuscaloosa, AL 35401
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
37
Abstract Views
343
PlumX Metrics