Confrontation in the Age of Plea Bargaining

56 Pages Posted: 2 Nov 2020

See all articles by William Ortman

William Ortman

Wayne State University School of Law

Date Written: September 30, 2020

Abstract

A defendant’s right to confront the witnesses against him is a cornerstone of our adversarial system of criminal justice. Or is it? Under current law, defendants can invoke their confrontation right only by going to trial. But trials account for about 5% of criminal convictions. That means that the overwhelming majority of defendants convicted in the United States never get to exercise their constitutional right to confront the government’s witnesses.

This Essay argues that the Supreme Court should align its Confrontation Clause jurisprudence with the reality of contemporary criminal justice. The Sixth Amendment grants a criminal defendant the right “to be confronted with the witnesses against him.” The problem is that the Court reads this text as if it said “the witnesses against him at trial.” Nothing compels the Court’s trial-centric gloss on what it means to be a witness. To the contrary, the Confrontation Clause’s text and purposes point towards recognizing that those whose “testimony” the government relies on in plea bargaining are “witnesses” too. This Essay therefore proposes a procedural device through which defendants could exercise their right to confront (i.e., cross-examine) that class of witnesses—the “Sixth Amendment deposition.” By conducting Sixth Amendment depositions, defendants would learn the strengths and weaknesses of the government’s evidence, enabling them to negotiate fairer and more reliable plea bargains. Sixth Amendment depositions would deliver to our “system of pleas” what confrontation at trial brought to an earlier version of American criminal justice—adjudication enhanced by adversarial testing of the government’s case.

Keywords: criminal procedure, criminal justice, plea bargaining, confrontation, Sixth Amendment

JEL Classification: K14, K41

Suggested Citation

Ortman, William, Confrontation in the Age of Plea Bargaining (September 30, 2020). Columbia Law Review, Vol. 121, 2021, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3702549

William Ortman (Contact Author)

Wayne State University School of Law ( email )

471 Palmer
Detroit, MI 48202
United States

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
78
Abstract Views
365
rank
352,379
PlumX Metrics