Case Comment: Undermining Children's Rights in A.M. v. C.H.

Claire Houston, "Case Comment: Undermining Children's Rights in A.M. v. C.H." (2020) 39 CFLQ 99.

11 Pages Posted: 19 Nov 2020

See all articles by Claire Houston

Claire Houston

Faculty of Law - Western University

Date Written: 2020

Abstract

The recent Ontario case of A.M. v. C.H. is troubling on multiple levels. The case involved a 14-year-old boy who was resisting contact with his father. The trial judge found that the mother had alienated the child from the father, despite evidence that the boy’s resistance was justified. The trial judge transferred custody to the father and suspended access between the child and the mother. The trial judge refused to review the order until the child agreed to "reconciliation therapy" with his father. After the custody transfer, the child assaulted the father, was criminally charged, and — prohibited from contact with the mother — was placed in foster care where he was seriously assaulted. Yet the significance of A.M. v. C.H. goes beyond its troubling facts. The trial judge’s decision and the Court of Appeal’s subsequent endorsement of that decision have implications for children’s rights more generally. This comment argues that A.M. v. C.H. threatens children’s rights in parenting disputes by allowing a judicial finding of alienation to silence children’s views, making it easier to reprimand custodial parents by transferring custody of children, and depriving capable children of autonomy to make treatment decisions.

Keywords: children's rights; family law; alienation

JEL Classification: K36

Suggested Citation

Houston, Claire, Case Comment: Undermining Children's Rights in A.M. v. C.H. (2020). Claire Houston, "Case Comment: Undermining Children's Rights in A.M. v. C.H." (2020) 39 CFLQ 99., Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3707402

Claire Houston (Contact Author)

Faculty of Law - Western University ( email )

1151 Richmond Street
London, Ontario N6A3K7
Canada

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
20
Abstract Views
56
PlumX Metrics