A Proposal to Revise and Simplify the Disruption Indicator
15 Pages Posted: 6 Jan 2021
Date Written: October 31, 2020
The disruption index (DI) based on bibliographic coupling and uncoupling between a document and its references, was first proposed by Funk & Owen-Smith (2017) for citation relations among patents and then adapted for scholarly papers by Wu et al. (2019). However, Wu & Wu (2019) showed that this indicator can be inconsistent. We propose a revised disruption index (DI*) which solves these issues and makes the indicator theoretically more robust and consistent. The sometimes small, but significant improvements are elaborated in simulations and empirically. The relation between “disruption” and bibliographic coupling is further specified.
Keywords: disruption, indicator, revision, bibliographic coupling
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation