Eradicating Bush-League Arguments Root and Branch: The Article II Independent-State-Legislature Notion and Related Rubbish

51 Pages Posted: 18 Nov 2020 Last revised: 3 Jul 2022

See all articles by Vikram D. Amar

Vikram D. Amar

University of Illinois College of Law

Akhil Amar

Yale Law School

Date Written: February 24, 2022

Abstract

The Court’s rulings in Bush v. Gore were disgraceful, and efforts two decades later to rehabilitate and recycle some of the worst aspects of the Court’s opinions in that litigation deserve loud condemnation by intellectually honest judges and scholars across the ideological and methodological spectra. In particular, the notion – advanced in recent years by litigants, several Justices and a few law professors – that Article II of the Constitution confers power on elected state legislatures, in regulating the selection of presidential electors, to disregard the very state constitutions that created and confine those legislatures, and the related notion that federal (rather than state) courts are in this setting the appropriate judicial interpreters of state election laws and state constitutional provisions, are utterly indefensible. The “Independent-State-Legislature” theory, as it is called by some of its proponents, runs completely counter to originalist and structural understandings of the Constitution in 1787, to actual state legislative practice and intentions, and to settled judicial precedent from the Court itself over the past century.

Suggested Citation

Amar, Vikram D. and Amar, Akhil (Reed), Eradicating Bush-League Arguments Root and Branch: The Article II Independent-State-Legislature Notion and Related Rubbish (February 24, 2022). 2021 Supreme Court Review 1 (2022), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3731755 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3731755

Vikram D. Amar (Contact Author)

University of Illinois College of Law ( email )

504 E. Pennsylvania Avenue
Champaign, IL 61820
United States

Akhil (Reed) Amar

Yale Law School ( email )

P.O. Box 208215
New Haven, CT 06520-8215
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
5,777
Abstract Views
24,122
rank
1,999
PlumX Metrics