Dialogue and Distrust: John Hart Ely and the Canadian Charter

Dialogue and Distrust: John Hart Ely and the Canadian Charter” (2021) 19(2) International Journal of Constitutional Law 1-17.

17 Pages Posted: 2 Dec 2020 Last revised: 20 Aug 2021

See all articles by Geoff Sigalet

Geoff Sigalet

McGill Research Group on Constitutional Studies; University of British Columbia

Date Written: November 18, 2020

Abstract

John Hart Ely’s process theory of judicial review has had an influence on constitutions across the globe. This article explores and evaluates Ely’s influence on the drafting and development of the 1982 Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The article first outlines the rudimentary elements of Ely’s theory of judicial review (II), then how Ely’s explicit influence on the development of Charter has mostly been limited to the context of section 15 equality rights (III). But Ely’s influence has been more extensive in the way scholars have sought to understand the Charter. The third section of this article shows how Ely has had an impact on Patrick Monahan’s theory of judicial review under the Charter, and in Rosalind Dixon’s process theory of dialogue. The article concludes by arguing that although Ely’s concerns remain relevant in the Canadian context, there are two reasons to be skeptical of using Ely’s theory to understanding Charter rights (IV): the first reason is that the Charter features substantive rights that do not seem to be reducible to protections for participation in the political process; the second reason is that process based dialogue theory appears to be insufficiently distrusting of courts.

Keywords: Ely, Charter, process theory, judicial review, equality rights, Monahan, Dixon dialogue

Suggested Citation

sigalet, Geoffrey, Dialogue and Distrust: John Hart Ely and the Canadian Charter (November 18, 2020). Dialogue and Distrust: John Hart Ely and the Canadian Charter” (2021) 19(2) International Journal of Constitutional Law 1-17., Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3732904 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3732904

Geoffrey Sigalet (Contact Author)

McGill Research Group on Constitutional Studies ( email )

Room 414, Leacock Building
855 Sherbrooke Street West
Montreal, QC H3A 2T7
Canada

University of British Columbia ( email )

Kelowna, British Columbia
Canada

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
50
Abstract Views
406
PlumX Metrics