Into the Multiverse: Replacing the Intelligible Principle Standard With a Modern Multi-Theory of Nondelegation
54 Pages Posted: 12 Mar 2021
Date Written: January 7, 2020
Following the split decision in Gundy v. United States, the Supreme Court now appears ready to reconsider the wisdom of the intelligible principle doctrine in the context of nondelegation. Over the past century, the intelligible principle has devolved into an unworkable standard; however, any new standard must grapple with the difficulty of creating a one-size-fits-all test for nondelegation. This Comment proposes a different path and advocates for the creation of a tripartite “Multi-Theory” of three separate nondelegation inquiries, grounded in a Youngstown-esque structural separation of categorical powers.
Keywords: Nondelegation, Intelligible Principle, Gundy, Youngstown, Gorsuch
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation