What's Right with Section 33.1

(2021) Canadian Criminal Law Review (Forthcoming)

Ottawa Faculty of Law Working Paper No. 2021-06

16 Pages Posted: 21 Feb 2021 Last revised: 29 Feb 2024

See all articles by Michael Plaxton

Michael Plaxton

College of Law, University of Saskatchewan

Carissima Mathen

University of Ottawa - Common Law Section

Date Written: February 10, 2021

Abstract

Section 33.1 has more than its share of critics. This paper reflects on what is right about section 33.1 – or at least the moral instincts behind it. The section articulates, however messily, values that find expression throughout the substantive criminal law, and reflects an abiding parliamentary interest in ensuring that its sexual assault reforms of the 1980s and 1990s are not undermined by the availability of a defence of extreme intoxication. The section promotes those values in an incoherent, constitutionally untenable fashion. But that is not to say that, if the provision is struck down by the Supreme Court, Parliament should simply throw in the proverbial towel. As others, including Paciocco JA in Sullivan; Chan, have observed, there are better, more principled ways to achieve the ends that Parliament sought to achieve with section 33.1: chiefly, to criminalize the reckless or negligent (over-)consumption of alcohol or drugs. The barriers to that approach are not constitutional but political.

Keywords: intoxication; Daviault; section 33.1; transferred fault; unintended consequences; voluntariness; criminal law

Suggested Citation

Plaxton, Michael and Mathen, Carissima, What's Right with Section 33.1 (February 10, 2021). (2021) Canadian Criminal Law Review (Forthcoming), Ottawa Faculty of Law Working Paper No. 2021-06, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3783298

Michael Plaxton (Contact Author)

College of Law, University of Saskatchewan ( email )

15 Campus Dr
Saskatoon, Saskatchewan S7N5A6
Canada
3069665894 (Phone)

Carissima Mathen

University of Ottawa - Common Law Section ( email )

57 Louis Pasteur Street
Ottawa, K1N 6N5
Canada

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
305
Abstract Views
1,155
Rank
183,836
PlumX Metrics