Solving the Procedural Puzzles of Texas’ Fetal-Heartbeat Law

39 Pages Posted: 18 Aug 2021 Last revised: 20 Aug 2021

See all articles by Charles W. (Rocky) Rhodes

Charles W. (Rocky) Rhodes

South Texas College of Law

Howard Wasserman

Florida International University (FIU) - College of Law

Date Written: August 17, 2021

Abstract

The Texas Fetal-Heartbeat Law enacted in 2021 as Senate Bill 8 prohibits abortions after detection of a fetal heartbeat, a constitutionally invalid ban under current Supreme Court precedent. But the method of enforcement in the Texas law is unique—it prohibits enforcement by government officials in favor of private civil actions brought by “any person.” Texas employed this enforcement mechanism to impose potentially crippling financial liability on abortion providers and advocates and to stymie their ability to challenge the law’s constitutional validity through offensive litigation in federal court to enjoin enforcement of the law. Texas lawmakers sought to confine abortion providers and advocates to a defensive litigation posture in state court.

This article works through the procedural and jurisdictional obstacles that SB8 creates for abortion providers and abortion-rights advocates seeking to challenge the constitutional validity of the fetal-heartbeat ban. While Texas has created a jurisdictional and procedural morass, the law does not achieve the ultimate objectives. Providers and advocates can litigate in federal court, although it requires creativity as to timing and proper litigation targets. They also should find greater success defending in state court than legislators expected or hoped. Other avenues remain to vindicate the rights of abortion providers and advocates—and the pregnant patients they serve--that accord with the traditional operation of and limitations upon the federal and state judiciaries in adjudicating constitutional rights.

Keywords: Federal Courts, Reproductive Freedom, Civil Rights, Procedure, Jurisdiction

Suggested Citation

Rhodes, Charles W. (Rocky) and Wasserman, Howard, Solving the Procedural Puzzles of Texas’ Fetal-Heartbeat Law (August 17, 2021). Florida International University Legal Studies Research Paper No. 21-15, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3906693 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3906693

Charles W. (Rocky) Rhodes

South Texas College of Law ( email )

1303 San Jacinto Street
Houston, TX 77002
United States
713-646-2918 (Phone)

Howard Wasserman (Contact Author)

Florida International University (FIU) - College of Law ( email )

University Park, DB 2065
Miami, FL 33199
United States
305-348-7482 (Phone)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
898
Abstract Views
2,509
rank
32,793
PlumX Metrics