Immigrant Legalization: A Dilemma between Inclusion and the Rule of Law?

27 Pages Posted: 1 Sep 2021

See all articles by Sarah Song

Sarah Song

University of California, Berkeley - School of Law; University of California, Berkeley; University of California, Berkeley - Berkeley Center on Comparative Equality & Anti-Discrimination Law

Irene Bloemraad

University of California, Berkeley - Department of Sociology

Date Written: July 2021

Abstract

Immigrant legalization policies pose an ethical dilemma for liberal democracies. On the one hand, liberal democracies aspire to respect the basic equality of all persons. Compelling moral arguments have been made for granting legal status and a path to citizenship to unauthorized migrants by virtue of the social ties that they have developed, their contributions to the host society, and their vulnerability to exploitation and subordination. On the other hand, legalization poses a challenge to another important value, the rule of law, which requires government to operate within a framework of law in accordance with well-established public norms, not in an arbitrary or ad hoc manner. Immigrant legalization programs are said to undermine the rule of law because they reward lawbreaking, allow queue-jumping, and incentivize further unauthorized migration.
This article clarifies each horn of the dilemma, focusing on rule of law arguments since less has been written about them. We assess both the empirical assumptions and normative interpretations embedded in rule of law arguments. We concentrate on the United States but also give some attention to legalization in other countries. We acknowledge that some of the rule of law objections to legalization have merit, but we argue that there are also rule of law arguments that support legalization, which help to mitigate, although not eliminate, the dilemma. We conclude by discussing the implications of our analysis and considering how liberal democratic states might better manage the dilemma.

Keywords: Amnesty, immigrant integration, immigration, legalization, regularization, rule of law

Suggested Citation

Song, Sarah and Song, Sarah and Bloemraad, Irene, Immigrant Legalization: A Dilemma between Inclusion and the Rule of Law? (July 2021). Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies Research Paper No. RSC 2021/61, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3913997 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3913997

Sarah Song (Contact Author)

University of California, Berkeley - School of Law ( email )

215 Boalt Hall
Berkeley, CA 94720-7200
United States

University of California, Berkeley ( email )

215 Boalt Hall
Berkeley, CA 94720-7200
United States

University of California, Berkeley - Berkeley Center on Comparative Equality & Anti-Discrimination Law

Boalt Hall
Berkeley, CA 94720-7200
United States

Irene Bloemraad

University of California, Berkeley - Department of Sociology ( email )

410 Barrows Hall
Berkeley, CA 94720
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
32
Abstract Views
180
PlumX Metrics