On the Evolving VAT Concept of Fixed Establishment

(2021) EC Tax Review 30(5/6), 201-206

8 Pages Posted: 11 Jan 2022 Last revised: 28 Feb 2022

Date Written: September 26, 2021

Abstract

The relevance of the concept of fixed establishment (FE) for the EU VAT system can hardly be over-stated. Similarly to the concept of permanent establishment (PE) for income taxes purposes, the term plays a central role in VAT, and is consistently relied upon by the legislator, for both determining the place of supply of services, and establishing the right to deduct input VAT. Yet, despite its significance, the term is far from clear, and in recent years, the debate over its definition and scope, primarily in the context of our global digital economy, has intensified. This paper considers the evolution of the concept of FE in EU VAT and the recent CJEU decision in Titanium in the context of the Court’s previous case law. It argues that existing inconsistencies are a mere reflection of the difficulties in providing an adequate response to the significant challenges posed by the globalisation and digitalisation of the economy. It further contends that whilst providing an effective and definite response to these challenges will likely require legislative reform, in the meantime the Court has a significant role to play in limiting the distortive impact of those challenges. Until now, its case law has often provided short-term relief to these challenges – even if not necessarily in a consistent and principle-based manner – however, as the recent decision in Titanium demonstrates, dealing with them on a longer-term basis will unavoidably require not only making difficult choices, but re-assessing established jurisprudence.

Keywords: Tax, VAT, Permanent Establishment, Fixed Establishment, Digital Economy

Suggested Citation

de la Feria, Rita, On the Evolving VAT Concept of Fixed Establishment (September 26, 2021). (2021) EC Tax Review 30(5/6), 201-206, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3938919 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3938919

Rita De la Feria (Contact Author)

University of Leeds ( email )

School of Law
Liberty Building
Leeds, LS2 9JT
United Kingdom

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
1,011
Abstract Views
3,126
rank
33,306
PlumX Metrics