The Pledge of Allegiance Revisited: Speech Rights vs Parental Rights

43 Pages Posted: 16 Nov 2021 Last revised: 18 Nov 2021

Date Written: October 12, 2021

Abstract

Since the Supreme Court decided West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette in 1943, free speech law has been clear: public schools may not force students to recite the Pledge of Allegiance. Nevertheless, in two states – Texas and Florida – students may decline to participate only with parental permission. The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the law on the grounds that the parental requirement furthered parents’ substantive due process right to control the upbringing of their children.

The Eleventh Circuit decision is flawed both in its understanding of the First Amendment right to be free of compelled speech and the substantive due process rights of parents. These mandatory pledge laws are viewpoint-based and therefore presumptively unconstitutional. While the free speech rights of students are more circumscribed than adults, none of the established justifications for curtailing student speech rights at school apply in this case. On the contrary, forcing students to pledge against their will exemplifies all the harms of compelled speech. Finally, parents’ constitutional right to control the upbringing of their children is meant to protect parents from the state, not to empower parents to trample on the rights of their children. In the end, the parental permission rule is simply a pretext for the state’s own viewpoint-based compulsion.

Keywords: First Amendment, Free Speech, speech, student speech, compelled speech, pledge, substantive due process, parental rights, schools, parents, black lives matter, Texas, Florida

Suggested Citation

Corbin, Caroline Mala, The Pledge of Allegiance Revisited: Speech Rights vs Parental Rights (October 12, 2021). Indiana Law Journal, Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3941233

Caroline Mala Corbin (Contact Author)

University of Miami School of Law ( email )

1311 Miller Drive
Coral Gables, FL 33146
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
106
Abstract Views
780
rank
327,017
PlumX Metrics