One Step Forward, Two Steps Back: The Unending Twist and Turn Regarding the Law of Khul‘ and its Exposition by the Superior Courts in Pakistan

Manchester Journal of Transnational Islamic Law & Practice (MJTILP) Volume 17, Issue 1:2021, pp. 133-149

17 Pages Posted: 21 Dec 2021

See all articles by Muhammad Munir

Muhammad Munir

International Islamic University, Islamabad - Department of Law

Date Written: October 21, 2021

Abstract

This article analyses the proactive judicial law making by the Peshawar High Court while deciding the Fakhar-ud-Din, and how the Hon’ble Supreme Court reversed, through it decision in the Yasmeen Bibi case, some of what was achieved in the former case. The main findings of this article are that in the Fakhar-ud-Din case, the Peshawar High Court has ruled that a Family Court should not order a wife to return the entire amount of dower if such Court is convinced that a husband has forced his wife to ask for khul‘ or when she is destitute, has no means and resources, and is unable to pay back the whole dower/mahr. However, in the Yasmeen Bibi decision, the Supreme Court has attributed many statements to Fakhar-ud-Din case that were never stated in it. Such assertions include that:1) the wife shall not return dower/mahr to the husband because a marriage contract cannot be valid and binding if its consideration or dower/mahr is not received by the wife; 2) in case of khul‘ the wife is required by the Qur’an not to return the dower; and 3) she has to return other benefits such as gifts given to her. The Supreme Court has also described marriage as a ‘civil contract’ and dower/mahr as its consideration. These remarks made by the Supreme Court have no basis in Islamic law as they are against the Qur’an and the Sunnah. Additionally, by ruling on the issue of repugnancy to Islam of Section 10(4) of the Family Courts Act, both the Hon’ble Supreme Court and the Peshawar High Court have intruded into the jurisdiction of the Federal Shariat Court, which has already ruled that the said provision was not against the injunctions of Islam.

Keywords: Khul‘; Marriage; Dower/Mahr; S. 10(4) Family Courts Act 1964; Islamic Law; Peshawar High Court; Supreme Court, Fakhar-ud-Din case, Yasmeen Bibi case

Suggested Citation

Munir, Muhammad, One Step Forward, Two Steps Back: The Unending Twist and Turn Regarding the Law of Khul‘ and its Exposition by the Superior Courts in Pakistan (October 21, 2021). Manchester Journal of Transnational Islamic Law & Practice (MJTILP) Volume 17, Issue 1:2021, pp. 133-149, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3946718 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3946718

Muhammad Munir (Contact Author)

International Islamic University, Islamabad - Department of Law ( email )

Islamabad, Islamabad Capital Territory 44,000
Pakistan
3335124423 (Phone)
0092-51-9258021 (Fax)

HOME PAGE: http://www.iiu.edu.pk

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
236
Abstract Views
847
Rank
235,448
PlumX Metrics