Property's Boundaries

57 Pages Posted: 28 Feb 2022 Last revised: 2 Sep 2022

See all articles by James Toomey

James Toomey

Elisabeth Haub School of Law at Pace University

Date Written: February 21, 2022

Abstract

Property law has a boundary problem. Courts are routinely called upon to decide whether certain kinds of things can be owned—cells, genes, organs, gametes, embryos, corpses, personal data and more. Under prevailing contemporary theories of property law, questions like these have no justiciable answers. Because property has no conceptual essence, they maintain, its boundaries are arbitrary—a flexible normative choice more properly legislative than judicial.

This Article instead offers a straightforward descriptive theory of property’s boundaries. The common law of property is legitimated by its basis in the concept of ownership, a descriptive relationship of absolute control that exists outside of the law. Ownership’s limits thus lie at the limits of absolute control—that which cannot in principle be the subject of human dominion cannot be owned. In short, the Article offers a comprehensive explanation for why a conceptual theory of property’s limits matters and how one can be possible, and defends a substantive theory of the concept of ownership as control.

Under this theory, cells, organs, gametes, embryos and corpses can be owned. But information—like genes and personal data—that cannot be controlled cannot be owned. Viewed through this lens, intellectual property—a challenge for any theory of property and which appears to entail ownership in information—can be understood either as a statutory analogy or a rough approximation of the real but temporary control of information exercised by those who create or discover it.

Keywords: property, bioethics, property theory, private law theory, law and technology, jurisprudence, adjudication, intellectual property

Suggested Citation

Toomey, James, Property's Boundaries (February 21, 2022). Virginia Law Review, Vol. 109, 2023, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4040141 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4040141

James Toomey (Contact Author)

Elisabeth Haub School of Law at Pace University ( email )

78 North Broadway
White Plains, NY 10603
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
327
Abstract Views
800
rank
136,738
PlumX Metrics