Are All ESG Funds Created Equal? Only Some Funds Are Committed
68 Pages Posted: 26 May 2022 Last revised: 13 Mar 2023
Date Written: March 15, 2022
Although flows into ESG funds have risen dramatically, it remains unclear whether these funds are truly committed to sustainable investments and how much their investments matter. We shed light on this debate by examining the incentives of fund managers. We find that conditional on similarly large ESG investments, ESG funds vary in their incentives to engage with portfolio firms. ESG funds with higher incentives to engage – committed ESG funds – hold their ESG investments longer, pay more attention to portfolio firms’ ESG risk exposure and implement less negative screening. They also demonstrate more discretionary voting on portfolio firms’ ESG proposals. Strikingly, only investments by committed ESG funds contribute to real ESG-improvements, and these funds have outperformed other ESG funds on their ESG holdings. Our paper highlights the importance of incentives when assessing the real impacts of sustainable investments and calls for greater investor awareness of a hidden form of greenwashing.
Keywords: mutual funds, ESG
JEL Classification: G11, G30
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation