Great Ambitions. The International Debate on AI Regulation and Human Rights in the Prism of the Council of Europe’s Cahai

Philip Czech et al. (eds). European Yearbook on Human Rights 2022. Cambridge, Intersentia, pp. 225-252. ISBN: 9781839702655

16 Pages Posted: 24 Jun 2022 Last revised: 17 Jan 2023

See all articles by Alessandro Mantelero

Alessandro Mantelero

Polytechnic University of Turin - Department of Management and Production Engineering

Francesca Fanucci

European Center For Not-For-Profit Law (ECNL); Central European University (CEU) - Center for Media, Data and Society

Date Written: April 4, 2022

Abstract

Over the past two years, the international debate on AI regulation has clearly escalated, with several initiatives led by the United Nations, the OECD, and the Council of Europe. Furthermore, at regional level, the EU proposal on a future regulation of AI and several national strategies have created a fertile ground for a more mature and elaborate debate.

In this regard, the initiative of the Council of Europe with the establishment of the Ad Hoc Committee on Artificial Intelligence (CAHAI), with its multistakeholder approach, the different legal cultures of Member States and Observers and the stakeholder participation process carried out, offers an interesting case study on the tensions underpinning the ongoing regulatory process.

Leaving aside the variety and creativity of ethical guidelines, developing binding provisions on AI entails addressing key and challenging issues related to the scope of the regulation; the interplay between international, national, and soft law; different approaches in crucial areas (dual-use, national security, deference, public sector, liability etc); and the role and nature of future AI supervisory authorities.

In this contribution, we analyse all these different elements not only from a traditional legal perspective, focused on the main outcomes of the CAHAI, but also by looking at the process and highlighting the underlying tensions, different points of view, consultation methodologies and the dynamics that make the dialogue on AI regulation an extremely interesting laboratory for human rights law.

The overall focus of our analysis is on the real ambitions that characterise the debate on AI regulation and how the initial high expectations of addressing crucial human rights issues risk being frustrated and limited to a general risk-based approach as well as a minimalist regulation which looks more to industry and economic benefits than to human rights. This, at a time when several academic researchers suggest adopting a broader perspective on the AI industry by considering its entire supply chain from a human rights standpoint, which also has relevance for the role of human rights in international business and competition.

Ultimately, our analysis also aims to underline how a human-rights-based approach does not stifle innovation but shapes it in the right direction for all the stakeholders involved, including civil society and marginalised, vulnerable groups, whose meaningful inclusion remains crucial in the regulatory debate.

Keywords: Artificial Intelligence, Human Rights, AI regulation, Council of Europe, Risk

JEL Classification: K00, K1, K19, K33

Suggested Citation

Mantelero, Alessandro and Fanucci, Francesca, Great Ambitions. The International Debate on AI Regulation and Human Rights in the Prism of the Council of Europe’s Cahai (April 4, 2022). Philip Czech et al. (eds). European Yearbook on Human Rights 2022. Cambridge, Intersentia, pp. 225-252. ISBN: 9781839702655, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4131299

Alessandro Mantelero (Contact Author)

Polytechnic University of Turin - Department of Management and Production Engineering ( email )

Corso Duca degli Abruzzi, 24
Torino, 10129
Italy

HOME PAGE: http://staff.polito.it/alessandro.mantelero/

Francesca Fanucci

European Center For Not-For-Profit Law (ECNL) ( email )

Netherlands

HOME PAGE: http://www.ecnl.org

Central European University (CEU) - Center for Media, Data and Society ( email )

Oktober 6. u. 7
Nador u.9.
Budapest, Budapest 1051
Hungary
07969917171 (Phone)

HOME PAGE: http://https://cmds.ceu.edu/francesca-fanucci

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
199
Abstract Views
874
Rank
315,412
PlumX Metrics