A Sixth Amendment Inclusionary Rule for Fourth Amendment Violations

43 Pages Posted: 11 Jul 2022

See all articles by Scott Howe

Scott Howe

Chapman University, The Dale E. Fowler School of Law

Date Written: June 24, 2022

Abstract

Early in the tenure of Chief Justice Roberts, a five-Justice majority of the Supreme Court signaled that it was ready to consider eliminating the exclusionary rule as a remedy for Fourth Amendment violations. The central concern was that, even after decades of limiting the rule through new exceptions, it purportedly lacked utility in balancing protections against the competing dangers of crime and police abuse, the only rationale on which it has been grounded in the modern era. That existential reappraisal never openly occurred, and the exclusionary rule, in further reduced form, still survives. Yet, given the Court’s recent conservative shift, there is reason to think that such a fundamental reassessment could now happen. On that view, the methods by which the Court could eliminate the exclusionary rule become important, as do some central normative questions that abolition would raise: In a world without court-ordered suppression, how, if at all, should the Constitution protect criminals against government searches and seizures? And how should it balance protection for law-abiders between the competing dangers of crime and police abuse? For the sake of exploring the implications, this Article assumes that the Court will, indeed, eviscerate the exclusionary rule as a judicially mandated remedy. The Article discusses four routes that the Court could follow. All of them, like the exclusionary rule, have defects. However, one stands out for protecting law-abiders somewhat from police overreach while only modestly protecting criminals and for resting on a constitutional grounding. The Court could substitute for the exclusionary rule an “inclusionary rule” based on the right to jury trial in the Sixth Amendment.

Suggested Citation

Howe, Scott, A Sixth Amendment Inclusionary Rule for Fourth Amendment Violations (June 24, 2022). Connecticut Law Review, Vol. 54, No. 3, 2022, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4145906

Scott Howe (Contact Author)

Chapman University, The Dale E. Fowler School of Law ( email )

One University Drive
Orange, CA 92866-1099
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
46
Abstract Views
252
PlumX Metrics