Constitutional Text, Founding-Era History, and the Independent-State-Legislature Theory

41 Pages Posted: 21 Sep 2022

See all articles by Dan T. Coenen

Dan T. Coenen

University of Georgia Law School

Date Written: September 19, 2022

Abstract

One question raised by proponents of the so-called independent-state-legislature theory concerns the extent to which state courts can apply state constitutional requirements to invalidate state laws that concern federal elections. According to one proposed application of the theory, state courts can never subject such laws to state-constitution-based judicial review. According to another application, federal courts can broadly, though not invariably, foreclose state courts from drawing on state constitutions to invalidate federal-election-related state legislation. This article evaluates whether either of these positions comports with the original meaning of the Constitution. Given the article’s focus on the originalist methodology, it directs attention only to the text of the Constitution and the context in which that text was drafted and evaluated in 1787 and 1788. This study of the relevant text and framing-era history—particularly as that history is disclosed by the Federalist Papers—casts a long shadow over the independent-state-legislature theory. At the least, it indicates that, as an originalist matter, there is no sound basis for broadly empowering federal courts to constrict state-court judicial review of federal-election-related laws under state constitutions, far less for precluding such judicial review altogether.

Keywords: constitutional law, originalism, independent-state-legislature theory, Moore v. Harper, Elections Clause

JEL Classification: K19

Suggested Citation

Coenen, Dan T., Constitutional Text, Founding-Era History, and the Independent-State-Legislature Theory (September 19, 2022). Georgia Law Review, Forthcoming Spring, 2023, University of Georgia School of Law Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2022-10, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4223731

Dan T. Coenen (Contact Author)

University of Georgia Law School ( email )

225 Herty Drive
Athens, GA 30602
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
97
Abstract Views
241
rank
386,079
PlumX Metrics