Rules

Kevin Tobia (Ed.), Cambridge Handbook of Experimental Jurisprudence. Cambridge University Press, Forthcoming

19 Pages Posted: 28 Apr 2023

See all articles by Guilherme Almeida

Guilherme Almeida

Insper

Noel Struchiner

PUC-Rio

Ivar Hannikainen

Department of Philosophy I, University of Granada

Date Written: April 17, 2023

Abstract

Rules are ubiquitous. They figure prominently in all kinds of practical reasoning. Rules are especially important in jurisprudence, occupying a prominent role in answers to the question of “what is law?” In this chapter, we start by reviewing the evidence showing that both textual and extra-textual elements exert influence over rule violation judgments (section II). Most studies about rules contrast text with an extra-textual element identified as the “purpose” or “spirit” of the rule. But what counts as the purpose or the spirit of a rule? Is it the goal intended by the rule maker? Or is purpose necessarily moral? Section III reviews the results of experiments designed to answer these questions. These studies show that the extra-textual element that's relevant for the folk concept of rule is moral in nature. Section IV turns to the different explanations that have been entertained in the literature for the pattern of results described in Sections II and III. In section V we discuss some other extra-textual elements that have been investigated in the literature. Finally, in section VI, we connect the results about rules with other issues in legal philosophy. We conclude with a brief discussion of future directions.

Suggested Citation

Almeida, Guilherme and Struchiner, Noel and Hannikainen, Ivar, Rules (April 17, 2023). Kevin Tobia (Ed.), Cambridge Handbook of Experimental Jurisprudence. Cambridge University Press, Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4421183 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4421183

Guilherme Almeida (Contact Author)

Insper ( email )

R Quata 300
Sao Paulo, 04542-030
Brazil

Noel Struchiner

PUC-Rio ( email )

Brazil

Ivar Hannikainen

Department of Philosophy I, University of Granada ( email )

Cartuja Campus
Granada, Granada 18071
Spain

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
184
Abstract Views
776
Rank
337,296
PlumX Metrics