Law and Order: The Timing of Mitigating Evidence Affects Punishment Decisions

Thinking & Reasoning (Forthcoming)

36 Pages Posted: 1 May 2023

See all articles by Emily Conder

Emily Conder

Vanderbilt University

Christopher Brett Jaeger

Baylor Law School

Jonathan Lane

Vanderbilt University

Date Written: April 18, 2023

Abstract

When we hear about a transgression, we may consider whether the perpetrator’s individual circumstances make their transgression more understandable or excusable. Mitigating circumstances may reduce the severity of punishment that is deemed appropriate, both intuitively and legally. But importantly, in courts of public opinion and of law, mitigating information is typically presented only after information about a perpetrator’s transgression. We explore whether this sequence influences the force of mitigating evidence. Specifically, in two studies, we examined whether presenting evidence about a perpetrator’s background before or after evidence of their violation influenced how severely U.S. participants punished perpetrators. In Study 1 (N=132), evidence about the perpetrator’s mitigating circumstances reduced punishment only when it was presented before evidence about the perpetrator’s violation. Study 2 (N=316) additionally revealed this moderating effect of presentation order across a variety of premeditated and impulsive violations. These findings are consistent with person-centered theories of punishment and with the Story Model of adjudication.

Keywords: transgressions, punishment, punishment decisions, extenuating circumstances, mitigation, mitigating, evidence, mitigating evidence, order effects

Suggested Citation

Conder, Emily and Jaeger, Christopher Brett and Lane, Jonathan, Law and Order: The Timing of Mitigating Evidence Affects Punishment Decisions (April 18, 2023). Thinking & Reasoning (Forthcoming), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4422699

Emily Conder

Vanderbilt University

Christopher Brett Jaeger (Contact Author)

Baylor Law School ( email )

Sheila & Walter Umphrey Law Center
1114 South University Parks Drive
Waco, TX 76706
United States

Jonathan Lane

Vanderbilt University

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
93
Abstract Views
322
Rank
474,484
PlumX Metrics