Dobbs, Plessy, and the Constitution of the New Jane Crow

40 Pages Posted: 1 May 2023 Last revised: 3 May 2023

See all articles by Evan D. Bernick

Evan D. Bernick

Northern Illinois University - College of Law

Date Written: April 28, 2023

Abstract

Tens of thousands of women and girls enter U.S. jails and prisons every year. Nearly a million are on probation, parole, or pretrial release. This carceral control is unevenly distributed, being primarily exercised over poor women of color. And it is growing. These realities are part of what has been conceptualized as “the New Jane Crow.”

This Essay contends that Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Org. gives the New Jane Crow the U.S. Supreme Court’s constitutional blessing. In justifying its decision to overrule Roe v. Wade and hold that the Fourteenth Amendment does not protect the right to terminate a pregnancy, Dobbs invokes Plessy v. Ferguson and its overruling by Brown v. Board of Education. The profound evil of Plessy’s constitutional endorsement of “separate but equal” railcars and its legitimation of Jim Crow segregation is said to illustrate the importance of overruling egregiously wrong precedents. But Justice Samuel Alito’s opinion for the Court in Dobbs has more in common with Plessy than its author recognizes.

Part I provides an overview of the New Jane Crow, tracing the genealogy of the phrase and describing the phenomenon that it names. Though provocative, I argue that the phrase fits the phenomenon, given substantive and functional continuities between state control of female reproduction past and present. Part II describes how Dobbs constitutionally legitimates key components of the New Jane Crow and encourages its expansion.

Part III analogizes Dobbs to Plessy in three respects. First, in its disregard of relevant history. Second, in its lack of attention to present socioeconomic realities. Third, in its capacity to provide constitutional legitimation to an entire political-economic order that perpetuates racialized and gendered subordination.

Keywords: abortion, constitutional law, the New Jane Crow, the New Jim Crow, fetal personhood, movement law, reproductive rights, reproductive justice, racial capitalism, race and the law, equal protection, Thirteenth Amendment, Fourteenth Amendment, Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Org.

Suggested Citation

Bernick, Evan D., Dobbs, Plessy, and the Constitution of the New Jane Crow (April 28, 2023). Northern Illinois University Law Review, 2023, Northern Illinois University College of Law Legal Studies Research Paper, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4432092 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4432092

Evan D. Bernick (Contact Author)

Northern Illinois University - College of Law ( email )

Swen Parson Hall
DeKalb, IL 60115
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
143
Abstract Views
686
Rank
394,735
PlumX Metrics